Monday, June 13, 2011

Mustapha Ajbaili: Erdoğan and Turkey’s quest for greatness

MUSTAPHA AJBAILI


Al Arabiya

I spent one day in Istanbul on my way from Dubai to Morocco last month. I stayed in a two-floor house converted into a pension located on a charming, cobblestoned street in a quiet area of Istanbul’s historic Sultanahmet district. The owner, Orhan, greeted me with a Turkish cup of tea, and then we began talking about the change taking place in the Arab world.
As we spoke, an election campaign van passed by. The van bore the slogan of the Justice and Development Party (AK Party) “İstikrar sürsün” (let the stability continue). I asked Mr. Orhan if Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan would be re-elected. He replied: “Oh yeah, there is no doubt about this. With Erdoğan, Turkey will be great again.”

For the ordinary man, Orhan, elections in Turkey were not merely about improving economic conditions or creating more jobs but more about restoring to the nation the greatness it had once enjoyed during the Ottoman Empire.

Mr. Orhan’s remarks made me reflect on the history of the power struggle in Turkey and how differing parties all unite around the common goal of building a great state.

Modern Turkey came to being following a war of liberation fought by Turkish nationalists against the Allies. Turkey was partitioned by the Allies following the Ottoman Empire’s defeat in World War I.

The Ottoman Sultanate was overthrown and Mustafa Kemal Atatürk came to power seeking to build a great state. Most successive leaders followed Mr. Kemal’s quest and ambition to build a great state but none was ever compared to him as Mr. Erdoğan has been.

Suzy Hansen, an American journalist based in Istanbul recently wrote of Mr. Erdoğan: “By now, Erdoğan is more than merely popular. He is a once-in-a-lifetime phenomenon, with all the political genius of a Bill Clinton and none of the personal excess […] If the AKP wins the June 12 elections, as is widely expected, Erdoğan will become the most powerful Turkish leader since Kemal Atatürk.”

(Mustapha Ajbaili, a senior editor at Al Arabiya English, can be reached at Mustapha.ajbaili@mbc.net)

Sunday, June 12, 2011

Mustapha Ajbaili: In Morocco, ‘Say the year is good!’



During a two-week visit to the North African Kingdom of Morocco, there have been music festivals of international grandeur, royal inaugurations of development projects and soccer celebrations across the country. The events widely publicized in the national broadcast media conveyed an image of normalcy being enjoyed by a country situated in a region swept by revolutions and social unrest.

But this type of publicity is often described by ordinary people as part of an official policy known as “goulou al-aam zeen” (Say the year is good!). This policy, people say, imposes a blackout on what the “Makhzan”—a word used to refer to the ruling establishment—sees as the kingdom’s dark side, which if brought to light could spur unrest, hurt the economy and the image of the regime abroad.


Indeed, there have been many more developments in the kingdom but these have received comparatively little media attention despite their high newsworthiness. There have been pro-democracy protests all over the country, brutal security crackdowns, and quasi paralysis in the sectors of health, education, judiciary and fisheries due to repeated nationwide strikes. Even the imams leading religious prayers in mosques have taken to the streets for the first time to demand better treatment by the government.

King Mohammed VI, the commander in chief of the armed forces and the “commander of the faithful,” distances himself from those problems, leaving an incapable government to deal with them. He appears on the national TV channels to highlight achievements and to deliver beautiful tidings. Watching the national media it takes no brilliance to recognize that the “good things” are attributed to the king and the “the bad things” are attributed to the government and to “radical elements” of the civil society. But regardless of who does what, the national broadcast media often highlight three active parties in the Morocco’s political scene—the king, the government and the civil society. The “makhzan”—or the hidden hand is never a player in the game.

At the time of writing hundreds of school teachers across the nation are in an open strike. They describe themselves as prisoners in “cell number nine.” Most of them have spent years in “grade nine” and have never been promoted to “grade 10” at a time when the ministry of education occasionally recruits waves of unemployed graduates straight to grade 10.

According to the law, a person first has to undergo a period of training as a teacher before he or she can be sent to class but the minister of education has issued exceptions to unemployed graduates constantly demonstrating before the parliament and government buildings and placed them in grade number 10, thereby angering teachers who have undergone training and still in grade number nine. Was the education minister not aware that his decision would plunge his sector into turmoil? A few teachers who spoke with the writer said it was impossible that the minister was not aware of his wrongdoing but that he had “no choice.”

“Our ministers have no choice, they do what they are asked to do and shut up even if it is wrong. When a problem breaks out in a government sector, the responsible minister can only wait for a call from the hidden man of the makhzan to tell him what to do,” a school teacher said.

Today there is much talk about a new constitution, the separation of powers and the institution of a system of regionalism that seeks to buttress local governance. Some people say the new reforms will take the nation to new heights in democracy building. Others cast a jaundiced eye on the anticipated reforms saying what the country needs most is strong law enforcement on all without exceptions.

On Friday, June 10, a columnist at Al Massae newspaper, whose executive editor was recently handed a one-year jail term for “criticizing the performance of the security forces,” asked whether it was acceptable for the interior ministry to crackdown on unauthorized peaceful demonstration demanding reforms while allowing another unauthorized demonstration to celebrate a soccer victory—a legitimate question that highlights a law enforcement problem.

(Mustapha Ajbaili, a senior editor at Al Arabiya English, can be reached at Mustapha.ajbaili@mbc.net)

Friday, May 20, 2011

The Obama Speech: Israel rejects peace plan, Palestinians wary, Arabs indifferent



MUSTAPHA AJBAILI

President Barack Obama initially didn’t quite get the enthusiastic response in the Arab world that some of his supporters may have expected as he outlined his vision of US foreign policy in the Middle East against the backdrop of pro-democracy uprisings sweeping the region.

Some Arab media pundits saw the Obama speech, the steps he has taken to impose sanctions on Syrian President Bashar al-Assad, and his pledge of support for the nascent democracies in Egypt and Tunisia, as encouraging and demonstrate a change in the US foreign policy.

But other commentators said the speech reflected the same time-honored US foreign policy approach of supporting a favored dictator until it became clear that he was losing control—then switching sides, claiming to be on the side of people, providing aid and doing whatever possible to re-instate the old system under a different name. In politics this is called: being on the right side of history.

Commenting on President Obama’s speech both Amr Hashem Rabie, of Al‐Ahram Center for Strategic Studies, and Hisham Melhem, the Washington bureau chief of Al Arabiya, agreed that the initiative in the Middle East today was in the hands of the people regardless of whether the US was genuinely siding with the people or not.

The Kuwaiti newspaper Al Rai revealed on Thursday that during a discussion earlier this week between President Obama and Jordan’s King's Abdullah II, the two leaders agreed that “It was impossible for the Assad regime to survive,” and that “the attention of Washington and its allies should now be focused on ensuring a smooth power transition stage in Syria.”

The newspaper quoted Tony Badran, expert on Syria, Lebanon and Hezbollah at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, saying, “Assad’s regime is finished” and that “it may hold on for a few months or more but it will eventually surrender to the wide opposition to its rule.”

This, according to the newspaper, explains the shift of the US policy toward Mr. Assad. President Obama seeks to position the United States on the side of the winner—the people.

In his speech, President Obama made it clear that the goals of the US Mideast foreign policy will remain the same, but that the strategy to achieve those goals will need to be fine-tuned.

“The question before us is what role America will play as this story unfolds. For decades, the United States has pursued a set of core interests in the region: countering terrorism and stopping the spread of nuclear weapons; securing the free flow of commerce, and safe-guarding the security of the region; standing up for Israel’s security and pursuing Arab-Israeli peace,” President Obama said.

He added that the US “will continue to do these things” but in a slightly different way.

“We must also build on our efforts to broaden our engagement beyond elites, so that we reach the people who will shape the future—particularly young people,” Mr. Obama said.

Israel on Thursday rejected President Obama’s call for a peace deal based the 1967 borders, as the Palestinians said their leadership would hold a meeting to discuss the US leader's policy speech.

Mr. Obama’s address, billed as an announcement of reoriented US policy in the Middle East after a slew of regional uprisings, focused heavily on the stalled talks between Israel and the Palestinians.

He called for a negotiated solution based on the borders that existed before the 1967 Six Day War, but also warned the Palestinians that a bid for UN recognition of a unilateral proclamation of statehood would not work.

“The borders of Israel and Palestine should be based on the 1967 lines with mutually agreed swaps, so that secure and recognized borders are established for both states,” said Mr. Obama. “The Palestinian people must have the right to govern themselves, and reach their full potential, in a sovereign and contiguous state.”

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, due to fly to Washington just hours after Mr. Obama’s speech, immediately called on the White House to guarantee Israel would not have to withdraw to the 1967 lines.

He urged Mr. Obama to commit to the assurances laid out in 2004 by then president George W. Bush, who said “new realities on the ground,” meant a “full and complete return” to the 1967 borders was “unrealistic.”

“Prime Minister Netanyahu expects to hear a reaffirmation from President Obama of US commitments made to Israel in 2004, which were overwhelmingly supported by both houses of Congress,” Mr. Netanyahu’s statement said.

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, however, welcomed Mr. Obama’s efforts to renew talks with Israel that collapsed last year, a senior Palestinian official said.

“President Abbas expresses his appreciation of the continuous efforts exerted by President Obama with the objective of resuming the permanent status talks in the hope of reaching a final status agreement,” said the official, Saeb Erekat.

Mr. Erekat, responding to Mr. Obama’s Middle East policy address, added that Mr. Abbas would soon convene “emergency” talks with Palestinian and Arab officials to consider further steps.

The Islamist Hamas movements immediately called on President Obama to take “concrete steps,” not merely issue “slogans” in support of Palestinian independence and an end to Israeli occupation.

“What Obama needs to do is not to add slogans but to take concrete steps to protect the rights of the Palestinian people and the Arab nation,” Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri told Agence-France Presse.


The New York Times reported:

“His message is clear,” said Muhsen Awajy, a dissident Islamist lawyer in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. “Do the job, and when you finish — when you have paid the price — we as Americans are ready to support our interests in a new phase.” He added: “It is a great country with great values, and he should translate that into timely intervention.”

The financial support that the president offered Egypt in the speech — forgiveness of $1 billion in debt — met with appreciation, but it was tempered for some Egyptians by memories of the tens of billions of dollars in aid that the United States gave to the authoritarian government of former President Hosni Mubarak over the years. Others said that Mr. Obama’s talk of support from the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund was likely to remind Egyptians of the economic liberalization under the Mubarak government — led by Mr. Mubarak’s banker son, Gamal — which enabled a small elite to accrue vast wealth.

“The Egyptian experience with both these institutions is totally negative, because the so-called structural economic adjustment that had been done only made the rich richer and the poor poorer,” said Hassan Nafaa, a political scientist at Cairo University who attended Mr. Obama’s speech in Cairo two years ago. “It seems that he is helping the capitalist system, and not taking into account the social situation in Egypt.”

In contrast to the fascination with President Obama’s address to the Muslim world in Cairo two years ago, or the rapt suspense at his comments toward his former ally Hosni Mubarak during the Egyptian revolution, Egyptians, Syrians, Libyans and Saudis generally professed only a dim awareness on Thursday of what was being said in Washington.

Even in Libya, where American-backed air strikes rain down on the forces of Col. Muammar Qaddafi, most patrons of a café in the rebel stronghold of Benghazi were more concerned with a local street protest against a man from the city who was still supporting Colonel Qaddafi as an anchor on state television.

“We’ve had long experience with American policy in the region, and we don’t trust Obama’s call for change in Syria,” said Abdel Majid Manjouni, head of the opposition Socialist Democratic Arab Union Party in Aleppo, Syria’s second-largest city. “Only the Syrian people can impose change, not the powers abroad.”

Still, some close observers said they detected a “new strategy” from Washington.

“We felt that for the first time that he was taking to us, and not to the leaders, as he did before,” said Mona Makram-Ebeid, a professor at American University in Cairo and a former member of the Egyptian parliament from a legally recognized liberal party. “This time he put his hands on the real problems that are affecting the different countries.”

Ms. Makram-Ebeid applauded Mr. Obama’s talk of tracking down the money stolen by ousted dictators and combating corruption.

“He is not just talking about democracy and human rights, he is talking about throwing back the shackles of the past and looking for hope for the future, and he spoke about the risks,” she said.

Some others around the region agreed that Mr. Obama’s professed support for the democratic movements in the region — “two leaders have stepped aside, more may follow” — sounded unlike the statements they heard during the first days of the uprising in Egypt.

“Everybody still has it in the back of their minds how America flip-flopped in their position toward these Arab revolutions,” said Amr Jarrad, 28, a banker in Amman, Jordan. “If you were so good in supporting autocratic regimes, why can’t you be so good in telling them to leave?”

In Riyadh, the Saudi capital, the speech fell awkwardly between two evening prayer times as the Arab weekend was beginning, so it was not easy to find people who had heard Mr. Obama speak. A few Saudi women dispatched Twitter postings underscoring that the president stressed gender equality in his remarks, and a few Saudi men said they thought the point might have been directed at them.

Saudi activists noted that Washington had already, as long ago as 2004, taken the line publicly that the Saudi monarchy had no choice to reform, but nothing tangible had come of it.

“With all these nice words, will it be transformed into policy?” said Mohammad F. al-Qahtani, a political activist. “That is a big if.”

That was the widespread reaction to the sections of the speech dealing with the Israeli-Palestinian dispute. In general, Arabs find it galling that American presidents rarely criticize Israel; while Mr. Obama did say, “the dream of a Jewish and democratic state cannot be fulfilled with permanent occupation,” some viewers found that insufficient.
In Cairo, Essam el-Erian, a spokesman for the Muslim Brotherhood and its newly formed Islamist political party, said the message to the Arab world was: “Do not wait to get any support from the White House, maintain your efforts and achieve your freedom.”



(Published in http://english.alarabiya.net/ on May 19)